Yeah, it's definitely granite; possibly Josh, Idyllwild, or even Woodson, but could also be granite in NH. I don't think it's the Valley. I've never been to Lumpy, AOR. It just looks so familiar, it's killing me!
I have a weird memory, Chip, there are things I remember way too well after way too long, and others of which I remember nothing aside from the bare fact of having climbed it before. So I have proudly claimed some Alzheimer's onsights.