Speaking of that final pitch not in the guidebook, has anyone else done it? It's the roof 15-20 feet left of the final pitch of Gaston/Gorilla My Dreams. It is the notch about 2/3 of the way out the Gaston variation traverse. I'm just shocked it's not recorded, especially because the gear is good and it's an obvious line.
Check your Swain guide if you have one. He has it written up as Gaston Direct, 5.10, FA unknown. Ivan also has something similar in his first (1981) Shanwangunk Grit guide, and he indicates that he did the FA in 1975.
You got it, Frank, good call! No chalk highway on this one. Nice pitch, I really liked it. Watch out for loose rock once you get around the corner, though. And on the ledge right below the crux too, lots of little rocks there.